Catch and Release – Really?
October 25, 2009
This week while sewing a button on my favorite sweater, I stuck myself at exactly the same time some mayor from Oregon on NPR was touting catch and release. Synchronicity, you ask. More like an attack of empathy, I answer.
As I sucked on my bleeding thumb, I listened to how catch and release is a way of not over fishing our streams and lakes. Too bad that as high as 35% of those fish who are caught and released die from the stress.
When I was a kid, my dad took me fishing. We fished at Perris Lake and Silverwood Lake, usually catching blue gill. Blue gill was easy to catch from shore with worms we had dug up from our own yard. As I got older, I had my own tackle box, fishing pole and my dad even spent the money for fish eggs and stinky cheese you wrapped hard around the hook. With the newfangled gear I had earned as a veteran fisherman, I had also the the responsibility of cleaning anything I caught. Now, this is a good argument for catch and release.
As if the fish isn’t stinky enough, you get to also pullout of all its entrails, taking a knife and gutting it. Oh, what fun. But then the dirty, sticky job of rubbing the outside of the fish to get as many of the scales off as possible is next. Of course, this is the exact moment your nose itches, a bug decides to crawl on your cheek, and that one stray hair falls into your eyes.
But we were not allowed to catch and release. We catch, we eat. Well, the rest of the family ate; I avoided the fish at dinner, preferring the OreIda french fries baked in our oven. I came from a family of waste not. Fishing was a not a sport, but a means of providing for a few meals.
Can you imagine catch and release hunting? Just shoot that deer in the leg, maim it a little so you can stand next to it and take a picture to show your friends, then let it go. Sure, it might die from the stress, not to mention that bullet wound in its hind quarters, but at least you didn’t kill it and eat it. No, you just wounded the poor thing, perhaps provided a slow death to it and then didn’t have the respect to eat it.
So, I cleaned my catch once then surprisingly found better things to do when my dad went fishing, my nails for example.
To this day, my dad does not catch and release. If he is going fishing it’s because he’s hoping for a fish dinner. And I should be more careful while sewing. Nothing stings like being stuck by a needle, having the needle pulled out and then bleeding for awhile.
This week I will catch and keep or not catch at all.